• Home
    • The Blog
  • Become a Truck Driver
    • Thinking of Becoming a Truck Driver?
    • Getting a CDL License
    • Truck Driving Jobs Guide
    • Trucking Company Guide
    • Trucker Life
  • CDL Training
    • Paid CDL Training
    • CDL Schools
    • Professional Driving Skills + Knowledge
  • Owner Operator
  • Just Trucks
  • Book a Consultation Now!

Smart Trucking

The Smart Trucking Survival Guide for the Trucker

What Truckers Need to Know About Forced Dispatch

February 6, 2020 By Catherine MacMillan

This post may contain affiliate links. You can read the full disclosure policy, which is pretty dull, but here it is.
41shares
  • 40

The concept of forced dispatch is one of my biggest pet peeves in the trucking industry.

Just what exactly is forced dispatch? This style of dispatching is when for example, a trucker doesn’t want to or is unable to go on the road for a trip for his company.

For whatever reason, he cannot or is unable to make a planned trip. The trucking company then proceeds to force the trip on the truck driver. The company indicates the driver must take the load.

As the saying goes, ‘Like it or lump it, you’re going to take it down the road and dump it’.  That’s forced dispatch.

The Teamsters Fought Forced Dispatch

Dispatchers pushing truck drivers, was quite prevalent in the early years of trucking. It was one of the reasons the teamsters came into being in the early 1900’s. They gained a lot of traction in the ’30’s under Hoffa’s leadership, because they were fighting hard against forced dispatch.

Teamsters Loose Ground, Forced Dispatch Gains

With the decline of the teamsters, forced dispatch now is beginning to come back. The large trucking companies base their profit margin on volume. They need to squeeze as much labour as they can, out of the truck driver, especially in these times of the severe driver shortage. It is starting to be a problem for truck drivers once again.

Forced Dispatch in Company and Owner Operator Fleets

This concept is mostly prevalent in company owned fleets. But it’s also becoming a problem in owner operator fleets as well.
Owner operators have a contractual agreement with the carrier they are leased on to. The contract may state that the owner operator must take a load when dispatched.
However, interestingly enough, at the same time, the company isn’t willing to guarantee the owner operator a fixed volume of miles or income, from the compulsory dispatch system. Certainly a clear discrepancy in the system.

FMCSA Says No Forcing a Driver on the Road

The FMCSA has brought forth a rule that it unlawful to coerce a driver to drive against his will. The reasons for refusing to drive can be for mechanical reasons, conflict with the hours of service regulations, the driver is ill, the driver is tired, or anything else which interferes in the safe operation of a commercial motor vehicle.

If a carrier is found guilty of coercion of a driver, the fines imposed by the FMCSA are very high, sometimes up to $16000 per incident. They would also be subject to the loss of their operating authority.

If the trucking company has been found guilty of the offence, they are not to take retaliatory measurements against the said driver, for refusing a load. Anything that affects the driver’s mileage or income, or job status, is considered a retaliatory measure.

Related > How to Get Along With Your Dispatcher Without Sacrificing Your Dignity 

How to File a Complaint Against a Trucking Company

The FMCSA accepts complaints of driver coercion. Emails over ELOGS can be used as backup in such a case. A driver can forward a message on the satellite system to his dispatch, stating the reason he is refusing the load.

If the trucking company then responds that the driver must complete the trip in question, they can be found at fault for forcing a driver to drive a commercial vehicle, in an unsafe manner.

HERE IS THE LINK TO SEND IN YOUR COMPLAINT REPORT TO THE FMCSA FOR INVESTIGATION.

The Truck Driver is ALWAYS Responsible When Behind the Wheel

The responsibility is with the driver if the driver is not fit to drive, and accepts the trip anyway. If something goes wrong, and the driver has an accident, the burden lies with the driver for knowingly driving when unfit to do so.

So it only stands to reason, when in doubt, as a professional driver, always refuse the load.

Related > What Truckers Need to Know About Their Dispatcher

Forced Dispatch Still Lives

Today with the mandate for E-logs being enforced, it has become much more difficult for carriers to force dispatch and stay within the FMCSA rules.

However, many unscrupulous companies will still attempt it.

One favourite trick trucking companies like to play is to take a driver just fresh off his ten hour break, work him for a few hours and then put him to bed again, while he is till fresh.

Then, 10 hours later, they’ll try to dispatch the driver for work again, this time for the full 14 hours.

Of course, the driver has not been able to sleep, as he was fresh off his first break and is just getting tired as his hours become available again.

While tricks like this may work well for the carrier, to have a driver available with full hours as a load becomes available, there has been no regard for the drivers circadian rhythm or sleep/wake cycles.

The company is trying to force a driver to work when he is tired. Clearly an unsafe practice.

Tricks such as this one, need to be fully documented by the driver, the load refused and reported to the FMCSA at the driver’s discretion.

With the truck driver shortage in full swing, trucking companies are less likely to get into an ugly situation with the driver and the FMCSA which they will not win.

A Positive Step Toward Protecting the Driver

This ruling is a big step toward solving a problem which has been prevalent in our industry for many, many years.  So just when we drivers think that the government is asleep at the wheel and do not care about what’s going on in trucking, down comes a ruling which is a huge step in the right direction.

So it seems they are certainly paying attention and making positive steps to end driver coercion.

Remember

  • Protect yourself as a professional driver.
  • Exercise your rights.
  • Don’t allow yourself to be pushed into unsafe situations. Don’t accept forced dispatch.
  • Forced dispatch is against the law.
  • You are responsible at all times when behind the wheel.

More Articles For You

  • 5 Important Things You Should Know About a Career in Trucking
  • Exactly What You Need to Know About Paid CDL Training
  • What You Need to Know About Owner Operator Vs Company Driver Jobs
  • A Guide to Kicking Off Your Trucking Career – Making That Big Decision

Filed Under: Trucker Life

Recent Articles

  • View of Highway from Big Rig Over Hood3 Smart Professional Trucker Tips to Protect Your CDL
    It's critical to protect your CDL. Some smart trucker tips to keep that CDL you've worked so hard for, clean and intact throughout your trucking career. […]
  • Truck Driver Standing Beside Blue PeterbiltDrive A Big Rig| It’s All I Ever Wanted To Do
    In spite of the problems in the trucking industry, there are still a number of truckers who stay with their career, as they love to drive. Dave laments on why he's stayed with the job, in spite of the industry and its faults. […]
  • Convoy of Big RigsTop Trucking Companies in Canada To Work For 2021
    We have curated a list of the top trucking companies in Canada to Work for in 2021: best paying, best for new drivers, tanker outfits, long haul carriers. […]
  • 5 Things Truck Driver Training Schools Don’t Teach |+ What To Do About It!
    Truck driver training schools don't teach ALL you need to know about driving a truck. We give 5 things you WON'T learn in CDL school + how to fix that! […]
  • 1981 International Transtar II BlueThe Old Big Rigs – What It Was Like To Drive Them
    A 42+ year trucker laments about driving old big rigs in the '70's and '80's: Transtar Cabover, R Model Mack, Western Star, Kenworth W900A, Cabover Freightliner […]
  • Experienced Veteran Truck Driver Smart Trucking Leaning on 379 Peterbilt5 Important Things You Should Know About a Career in Trucking
    I have learned a lot from my 40 years as a professional driver. There are 5 things that every one considering a truck driving career and those who are new to the industry should know. […]

Search This Site

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Our Latest Articles

  • 3 Smart Professional Trucker Tips to Protect Your CDL
  • Drive A Big Rig| It’s All I Ever Wanted To Do
  • Top Trucking Companies in Canada To Work For 2021
  • 5 Things Truck Driver Training Schools Don’t Teach |+ What To Do About It!

Our Most Popular Articles

  • 7 Things You Need To Know About Your First Year as a New Truck Driver
  • What Professional Truck Drivers Do Differently Than the Rest
  • Winter Driving Tips For the Trucker | A Professional’s Safety Guide
  • 10 Truck Driving Safety Tips Every Professional Driver Should Follow
COPYRIGHT 2012-2020, SMART TRUCKING | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

PLEASE NOTE: This site contains affiliate links. If you click on one of the product or service links on this site, we may receive commissions if you purchase something. Please note: we would not recommend any product/service we would not use ourselves. Learn more...

Home   |    Affiliates & Disclosures   |   Privacy   |    Advertising   |   Disclaimer   |   Contact   |   Who We Are   | Terms + Conditions   | Sponsorships
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.